ZFS or SnapRAID
Posted: October 30th, 2013, 10:16 am
Hi there, I stumbled upon this fantastic site while researching ideas for my home server. I've bought (and am awaiting delivery of) all of the bits that I'll need (I already have a box with suitable mobo/ram/cpu but I've got 8 x 4tb drives, a pci-e 4-port sata card and an ssd incoming).
I *did* have a pretty clear idea of what I wanted to do. The plan was to put Mint on the box (this is my first Linux adventure and I've read many good things about Ubuntu and Mint especially from a noob pov) and then to use zfs to put the disks in a raidz array.
Now I'm reading about SnapRAID and KVM's (in the virtualisation sense) and thinking that running Ubuntu Server at the core would be a great idea and then maybe a Mint VM on top of that? I chose Ubuntu and Mint for the aforementioned usability reasons but also because I've found Ubuntu versions of packages I currently use on the box in win7 (mostly Handbrake and jdownloader).
In my planning, I went from RAID cards (LSI, Highpoint etc) straight to ZFS and hadn't heard of FlexRAID or SnapRAID until I saw this website. So, I guess the main point of this thread is: SnapRAID or ZFS? I've seen the comparison on the SnapRAID site but does anybody have real world experience with both?
Anyway, thank you very much for this guide. It's really incredible how you've explained everything. I consider myself very proficient in a windows environment but completely out of my depth in anything else. I also very much like your thin client idea but that's a project for a later date!
Edit - I should point out that I'm approaching this with 8 new (obviously empty) drives so the fact that I can put SnapRAID into use on a drive full of data shouldn't be considered a benefit (as awesome as it is) in this scenario.
I *did* have a pretty clear idea of what I wanted to do. The plan was to put Mint on the box (this is my first Linux adventure and I've read many good things about Ubuntu and Mint especially from a noob pov) and then to use zfs to put the disks in a raidz array.
Now I'm reading about SnapRAID and KVM's (in the virtualisation sense) and thinking that running Ubuntu Server at the core would be a great idea and then maybe a Mint VM on top of that? I chose Ubuntu and Mint for the aforementioned usability reasons but also because I've found Ubuntu versions of packages I currently use on the box in win7 (mostly Handbrake and jdownloader).
In my planning, I went from RAID cards (LSI, Highpoint etc) straight to ZFS and hadn't heard of FlexRAID or SnapRAID until I saw this website. So, I guess the main point of this thread is: SnapRAID or ZFS? I've seen the comparison on the SnapRAID site but does anybody have real world experience with both?
Anyway, thank you very much for this guide. It's really incredible how you've explained everything. I consider myself very proficient in a windows environment but completely out of my depth in anything else. I also very much like your thin client idea but that's a project for a later date!
Edit - I should point out that I'm approaching this with 8 new (obviously empty) drives so the fact that I can put SnapRAID into use on a drive full of data shouldn't be considered a benefit (as awesome as it is) in this scenario.